Thistlewoods' Website
A strange Sowerby moment in history
|
|
Back in the late 1990s we bought this commemorative bust, in frosted flint glass, admittedly without knowing too much about it. Because we collect pressed glass and we also collect Royal and political commemoratives, this item ticked both boxes. The inscription on the front is CORONATION 12 MAY 1937 so clearly it is a Royal commemorative (see larger picture and detial below). Who made it? |
|
Despite intensive searches of catalogues, the maker eluded us until some time later, almost by chance, we looked at a copy of the Pottery Gazette and Glass Trade Review for 1st Oct 1936. To our complete amazement we saw this Sowerby advertisement for their various 1937 Coronation commemoratives, and there it was in the centre of the ad – confirmed as a Sowerby item!
Then in 2007 we saw another example, this time in amber glass. It was in the Broadfield House Museum’s storage facility at Hinckley Hall, which had been specially opened to members of the UK Carnival Glass Society.
The next part of the story is that we saw one of these busts, again in amber, on a dealer’s stall - see below, and here is where it gets more interesting. The dealer also had a similar commemorative, in frosted flint glass, with the same inscription (CORONATION 12 MAY 1937) …. but with a different person’s head! Why?
The answer is in a piece of somewhat bizarre British history. Two different kings had announced they were to be crowned on the same date: 12 May 1937. When King George V died in 1936, under British succession laws his eldest son Edward VIII became king and the Coronation was set for 12 May 1937.
However, the British political and religious establishment would not agree to Edward marrying the divorcee, Wallis Simpson, and in order to marry her, Edward decided to abdicate the throne in December 1936. Although he had been king, the Coronation had not taken place, and he was never actually crowned.
George V’s second son, George VI ascended the throne in his brother Edward’s place. It was decided that because plans for the Coronation (of Edward VIII) were so advanced in Britain and around the world, George VI’s Coronation would thus be on the day that had already been fixed for Edward. |
|
Even in those days, producing Royal commemoratives was big business, and there would have been lots of work to be done designing and producing them in advance of the “coronation that never happened” – that of Edward VIII. There are many commemorative items around, particularly pottery and china items, erroneously proclaiming Edward’s “coronation” on 12 May 1937.
Sowerby were also taking advantage of this lucrative market, and like many makers of Royal commemoratives, they must have been shocked when Edward abdicated. What did they do? Actually two things: clearly some Edward commemoratives had already been sold – but, as these glass busts are quite rare, we suspect that Sowerby removed them from sale, after only two months or so. Secondly, they decided to re-cut the mould and replace George’s head with Edward’s. The neck, medal, shoulders and uniform are otherwise identical, only the heads are different. They would not have had much time to do this and get them onto the market, so there are probably very few in existence and in fact this is the only one we have seen. So, two busts of different kings with the same “coronation” date – an unusual bit of British history.
|
King Edward VIII commemorative bust (in frosted flint glass)
|
|
King George VI commemorative bust (in frosted flint glass, left, and amber, right) |
|
Detail showing the two different heads on the busts - left is Edward VIII, and right George VI |
A rather spooky footnote – the picture on the Sowerby ad looks remarkably like the image of George, not Edward, but the Pottery Gazette is dated October 1936 - that is, before Edward announced his abdication, so it must have been intended to depict Edward’s bust, that is, unless conspiracy theorists think Sowerby somehow knew otherwise ……
|
Copyright © G&S Thistlewood 2009. All Rights Reserved. No image or text or any part thereof may be copied without permission from the Copyright holders. |